Steve’s Media Blog

Book Review Time!

Posted on: November 27, 2008

I had to get this one off my chest – I was only thinking about it because I’m in a writing mood, and I am thinking about finances.  Moving along, the reason I borrowed this book from the library (good thing I only borrowed it) is because I have been on a kick about reading personal finance books in an effort to improve my money situation.  This one came along because it was flashy and sounded like it had promise – or at least not a dry read.

A Million Bucks by 30: How to Overcome a Crap Job, Stingy Parents, and a Useless Degree to Become a Millionare Before (or after) Turning Thrity by Alan Corey is the book.  See?  I told you it was flashy.  I probably should have realized from the title that it was going to be a lot of sensationalism there and there wouldn’t be much substance to the book.  Good news for Mr. Corey: his title worked and I picked up the book.  Unfortunately for him, I didn’t buy it.  1-0 for me, I believe (though when you realize I linked to both his book and his website, I guess that makes it 1-1).

The write-up at the back of the book should have also given away what kind of read it was going to be.  See here:

At twenty-two, Alan Corey left his mom’s basement in Atlanta and moved to New York City with one goal in mind: to become a millionaire by the time he was thirty. His parents and friends laughed, but six years later they were all celebrating his prosperous accomplishment–at a bar Corey owned in one of Brooklyn’s hippest neighborhoods.

No, Corey didn’t climb the corporate ladder to build his fortune. In fact, he worked the same entry-level 9-to-5 job for six years straight. But by pinching his pennies and making sound investments, he watched a pittance blossom into a seven-digit bank account. In A Million Bucks by 30, Corey recounts his rags-to-riches journey and shares his secrets to success.

I won’t deny that his is an interesting and quasi-well told story, but I maintain that beyond the story telling there is no substance to this book.  Beyond having a stated goal in mind (become a millionare by 30) and proving that determination trumps all, Corey has nothing to offer in this book beyond faint hope.

His tips in the book are generic ones – and he himself admits that living on ramen noodles for three months isn’t the best solution for everyone.  Seriously, that’s how he saved money: he lived on ramen noodles for all his meals.  I will admit that some of the tips are OK – but only OK.  He bought a playstation so that he could avoid going out once or twice a week.  Big investment up front for saving money (though honestly, I would probably go for something used and older because otherwise the money he saved from going out every week would probably equal what he spent on the playstation).

In general I feel that the book is more of an autobiography than a helpful finance book.  Particularly because most of the reasons for his success rely on pure luck: a big real estate agent liked the property that he and his partners renovated.  He got himself on TV a bunch of times (the subsequent appearances weren’t luck so much as a result of the first few times).  He lucked into finding a bar with a sour owner looking to sell.  He lucked into a book deal.

I find that he also glossed over several things – he didn’t take the time to explain all of his methods.  I grant that would make the book a little drier to read, but I think it is a bit silly for him to suggest that other people can make millions if he can – except that he doesn’t want you to know exactly how he did it.

Like I said, I won’t doubt that his determination definitely help drive his finances into the million mark; but his lifestyle is not for everyone and his methods aren’t for everyone.  How comfortable are you about flipping real estate?  I know I’m not.  He has good ideas for things that worked for HIM, but maybe not for everyone else.

Listen, I would avoid this as a helpful guide to your finances.  If you enjoy reading success stories, it’s not bad though.

Advertisements

1 Response to "Book Review Time!"

[…] Book Review Time! … probably equal what he spent on the playstation). In general I feel that the book is more of an autobiography than a helpful finance book. Particularly because most of the reasons for his success rely on pure luck: a big real estate agent liked the property that he and his partners renovated. He got … […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: